Should children learn about advertising in school and if
so, what do teachers need to understand about the way in which children engage
with advertising?
Research has found that contemporary children are growing
up watching some form of electronic media daily (Cooke 2002) thus being exposed
to advertising due to it increasingly being accessed by children via television
and other media (Gunter, Oates & Blades 2005). Livingstone and Helsper (2006) found that
‘there is evidence that children of all ages are affected by advertising’
(Banaji 2010: 63) and that children are ‘more vulnerable […] to the effects of
media ' (Banaji 2010: 63). Advertising to children is surrounded by
controversy, with it often being suggested that children ‘need protecting from
the effects of advertising in general or from the advertising of particular
product’ (Gunter et al 2005: 2) however, Himmelweit et al. (1958), believes
that advertising empowers children as consumers in a changing (increasingly
globalised) economy (Himmelweit et al. 1958 as cited in craft 2012).
As a trainee teacher, the controversy’s need to be
considered for use of adverts in the 21st century classroom. I feel
that adverts although can be seen as harmful or impose a negative influence on
children, they can serve a useful purpose within the literacy context. They
allow children to explore their personal preferences and develop items of
interest to them however, Gunter et al 2005) argue that this can lead to ‘pester
power’, meaning that they persist asking parents for inappropriate or expensive
items. IN the classroom adverts can be used as a valuable resource as a tool
for writing with a particular focus on persuasive texts. Adverts are seen as an
invasive medium that effectively influence consumers in their own home (Gunter
et al 2005), but do children know or understand the full impact of what they
are viewing. Blackburn (2008) suggests that it is important for pupils to
interpret what they see thus needing a repertoire of knowledge surrounding advertising
vocabulary, intentions and purpose.
Word count: 306
Bibliography
Banaji, S. (2010) ‘Analysing Advertisements in
the Classroom’ in Bazelgette, C.
(Ed) Teaching Media in Primary Schools. London: SAGE
Blackburn, B. (2008) ‘Literacy from A to Z’ New York: Eye on
Education
Craft, A. (2012)
‘Childhood in a digital age: creative challenges for educational futures’ in London Review of Education, 10 (2), pp.
173-190.
Gunter, B., Oates, C. & Blades, M.
(2005) ‘Advertising to
Children on TV’ New Jersey, Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. pp1 – 13
Livingstone, S. & Helsper, E. (2006)
‘Does advertising literacy mediate the effacts of advertising on children? A
critical examination of two linked research literatures in relation to obesity
and food choice’, in Journal of
Communication, 56 (3) pp.560-584
I agree that children need to be able to form their own informed opinions about products, but does teaching them to pick holes in advertisements make them less likely to be good adult consumers? Do we want to guide children away from buying things throughout their lives, when this helps to drive the economy?
ReplyDeleteThere is undoubtedly pressure for parents to buy items related to crazes and materialism. There is also evidence which suggests that parents spend more when they are shopping with their children than without. This demonstrates that this 'pester power' can have a genuine effect.
I do not think that we should guide children away from becoming consumers however we should make them aware of how adverts are produced and there purpose.
ReplyDelete