There is controversy surrounding the use of popular
culture within the primary classroom, and due to children being increasingly
‘exposed to new technology’ (Blake, Winsor and Allen 2012; 26), ‘the concept of
literacy has broadened’ (Rose 2008; 37). Marsh, Brooks, Hughes, Ritchie,
Roberts and Wright (2005) found that ‘parents were generally very supportive of
the role that popular culture, media and new technologies play in their
children’s lives’ (Marsh et al 2005; 46), however, Lambirth (2003) found that
some practitioners hold an opposing view stating that ‘they get enough at home’
(Lambirth 2003; 9). On the contrary, other educators believe that popular
culture is ‘very prominent and […] has a big impact’ (Arthur 2005 cited in
Marsh 2005: 175) in children’s lives.
When conducting a survey on student teachers, I found
that they also held diverse views on the inclusion of popular culture in the
classroom. Each of the three students I surveyed, said that popular culture
should be used in the classroom however, student A held the view that they
should be used with caution as some aspects of popular culture could influence
children and distract them from the task in hand, this is supported by
Buckingham and Scanlon (2001) as they state that ‘popular culture icons
penetrate every aspect of children’s lives’ (Buckingham and Scanlon 2001 cited
in Marsh 2005; 167).
With popular culture increasingly involving the use
of technology, it is fundamental that ‘all children are taught to read and
write in conventional ways’ (Dean 2010; 52). Student B and C supported this
however, believed that the use of popular culture being introduced within the
classroom context would benefit children and motivate them to complete a task.
Conversely, Dean (2010) suggests that the use of popular culture and the new
medias that are readily available in the classroom is ‘capable of distracting […]
from classroom studies’ (Dean 2010:54).
Word Count: 311
·
Blake, S. Winsor, D. and Allen, L. (2012)
‘Technology and young children: Bridging
the communication- generation gap’ Hershey: IGI Global
·
Dean, G. ‘Rethinking
Literacy’ in Bazalgette, C. (ed)
(2010) Teaching media in primary
classrooms London: Sage
·
Lambirth, A. (2003) ‘”They get enough of that
at home”: Understanding aversion to popular culture in schools’ in READING Literacy and language 37 (1) pp.
9-13
·
Marsh, J., Brooks, G., Hughes, J., Ritchie, L.,
Roberts, S., & Wright, K. (2005) ‘Digital beginnings: Young children’s use of popular culture, media and new technologies’
University of Sheffield pp.46-49
·
Marsh, J. (2005) ‘Popular Culture, new media
and digital literacy in early childhood’ Oxon: Routledge Falmer
·
Rose, J. (2008) ‘The Independent Review of the
Primary Curriculum: Interim Report’ London:
Department for Education
I agree with the point you highlighted about using popular culture in the classroom with caution as it may cause a distraction for children. I think the decision to incorporate popular culture into lessons should be based on our personal opinions of the class and whether our children will respond positively to its' presence and support their learning. I think it could be easy to get carried away and almost end up relying upon popular culture to get the children excited and motivated to learn, so I think its very important for clear boundaries to be set and that the children understand that they will have to learn the conventional way too.
ReplyDeleteI think that the notion of popular culture taking over is quite possible and Evans (2004) raises the similar question of how often we should integrate pupil’s interests into the curriculum. However, a possible solution for popular culture not taking prominence in the classroom is the fact that technology and children's popular culture artefacts are likely to change more quickly then we can keep up with (Halsey, 2007).
DeleteCan we use technology but still use traditional methods or once we accept that technology alters the mode of teaching does it become popular culture?
ReplyDeleteI think that we can use technology in the classroom and it not become popular culture depending on the context it is used in.
ReplyDelete